I was about to cross the road last Sunday when this double decker bus stopped just before the traffic lights. On it was a picture of a beautiful model. About 10 seconds later, the bus sped off with me managing to catch a second glimpse of the picture belonging to a slimming advertisement. Then it suddenly dawned upon me that I did not know which slimming company the ad was for. I had totally lost out on the branding, the messaging, and more importantly, the call to action.
Anyone could argue that I was distracted by the beautiful model, but hey… like there was anything better on that ad to catch my attention.
I have been in the media business for about 10 years… selling… planning… consulting, I’ve done it all. But till date, I dare say that despite all the assurances I used to make my clients (and all the assurances the media owners used to make to me), I still can’t guarantee which media platform actually works, and which don’t. (Honestly, I don’t think my media colleagues can either) Then what more for clients? Well, at least the big guys have multi million dollar media tools to justify million dollar budgets to their management. And if the media strategy is half decent, you can’t go very wrong with the dailies or TV can you?
But how about you, the small business owner?
It’s $3,000 a spot on TV on average, and $5,000 for a half page b/w ad in ST. How many of these can you afford to buy in order to make strong impact?
The media scene in Singapore is well regulated (with no fraud), but if you are working on a shoestring budget, it makes a lot more sense to think a little deeper into the options available to you.
Target audience and quality of traffic
It’s déjà vu all over again because I’ve seem to have said this a thousand times before. You need to know your customers well; their needs, their habits, their motivation to buy. The more you know about them, the easier it is to sell. And so, the quality of traffic exposed to a particular media is of utmost importance. For e.g. the circulation of Straits times is 1.5million. Does it make sense then to buy an ad in ST? Well, that depends on how many of your customers read ST. Then there are the other factors to think about… like what size do you buy in ST? Is it more effective to buy a small ad in ST, or a bigger ad in TODAY, where circulation in lower? How many of your highest spending customers read TODAY? Which publication offers higher visibility and retention?
Environment
Consumers behave differently in different situations. You need to be able to identify how your customer is likely to react in a particular ad environment. Example 1: if you are selling baby’s clothes, is it more effective to advertise in ST (where readers are likely to speed read), or would your ad dollar be better spent in a magazine (where readers will probably read at a more leisurely pace)? Example 2: if you have a small store in a mall, would you run an ad on TV where customers would take a few days to ponder before finally going down? Or are you better off buying a billboard space within the mall, and to run a special promotion to encourage impulse buying.
Communication message
Again, different media platforms call for relevant communication strategies. Consider the consumer behavior at the point of contact. How much time do I have to view the ad before I turn the next page or walk away? What is the consumer take away from the ad that you want to achieve? How do you best deliver the takeaway. I’ve always loved what McDonald’s and OCBC do with their bus stop panels. They just put up an arrow, leading you to the closest outlet. Simple and effective. The outcome of this is that even before you step into a particular mall, the first brand that you have encountered would have already been McDonald’s and OCBC. This is especially effectively when a consumer is likely to be drowned in a sea of options the moment he/she steps in.
Return on investment
Most small businesses jump on the advertising bandwagon without even knowing what’s in it for them at the end of the day. As a young ad sales executive, I used to sell ad space by painting an absolutely beautiful picture on how a business can become a global brand by running a campaign. That’s absolute bullshit! Any half decent marketer will know that brands require years and millions of dollars to build. ‘Just do it’ didn’t suddenly become the next big thing overnight. More importantly, how does the result of branding ring the cash registers? No one’s going to love ‘I’m loving it’ if it doesn’t get burgers off the shelf. Before you embark on buying a media, also consider costs, versus what it means to you in terms of money back.
I have previously written a post on branding and selling for small businesses.
Objectives
Summarizing what’s been said above, you need to have a clear idea on what your objectives are when buying into a medium: 1) Is it short or long term? Do you have the means to see through the campaign? A sudden discontinuation will often result in a major loss for the advertiser. 2) Is the campaign tactical or are you just trying to build awareness? For awareness building, do not expect a sudden influx or traffic to your store. 3) How much are you expecting to earn from the campaign? 4) What actions do you want your customers to take after seeing the ad? Sign up for your Facebook page or take advantage of a promotion? Are you looking to change consumer perceptions? Is this the best media to achieve that?
And to end off, always talk to you sales rep about discounts. There’s no media owner who doesn’t set aside 15-30% for discounts, volume or not.


